Trusts can be valuable estate-planning tools. They can also introduce expense, administration and restrictions that a family neither needs nor wants. So, if you are making a Will, should you include a trust? The answer depends on what you are trying to achieve.
What is a Will trust?
A trust is an arrangement under which your chosen trustees hold and manage assets for the benefit of other people. A Will trust generally comes into effect on death, although exactly how it operates depends on the terms of the Will.
Not every reference to a trust in a Will means that your family will have to administer a complicated, long-running arrangement. For example, Wills often establish a children’s trust to hold an inheritance for a child who has not yet reached the specified age – often ages 18, 21 or 25. The important question is, what the trust is intended to achieve in practice.
When might a Will trust be useful?
There are circumstances in which a carefully drafted trust can provide real protection or flexibility.
Second marriages and blended families
Someone may want their spouse or partner to be able to live in the family home for the rest of their life, while ensuring that their own share ultimately passes to their children. A properly structured life interest trust may help achieve that balance very successfully. The ownership of the property, mortgage arrangements and other assets all need to be considered.
A beneficiary who needs additional protection
A trust may be appropriate where a beneficiary is vulnerable, has a disability, or may struggle to manage a substantial inheritance. The right structure depends on their circumstances, including any means-tested benefits and the practical responsibilities being placed on trustees.
Flexibility where circumstances may change
In some families, a discretionary trust may be useful because it allows trustees to decide when and how beneficiaries should benefit. But flexibility comes with responsibility and the need for later decision-making: trustees must make decisions, keep records and comply with their legal and tax obligations.
Why not include a trust just in case?
A trust is not a free extra layer of protection. Depending on the type of trust and the assets involved, there may well be ongoing tax reporting requirements, trust registration, professional fees, record-keeping and decisions for trustees to make. Some trusts also face ongoing, additional tax charges.
That does not make trusts a bad idea. It means that their benefits should justify their costs and restrictions. A complicated Will is not necessarily a better Will.
Will a trust protect my home from care fees?
This is an area where sweeping promises should be treated with caution. Trusts are sometimes marketed as a way to protect the family home from future care costs, but there is no universal solution. Local authorities may consider deprivation of assets rules, and the outcome depends on the facts, the timing and the particular arrangement. A trust should not be recommended on the basis of a guaranteed care-fee saving.
What about inheritance tax?
Putting assets into trust does not automatically save inheritance tax. Different trusts have different tax consequences, and some can give rise to charges during the lifetime of the trust or when assets leave it. The inheritance tax position also depends on the wider estate, available exemptions and reliefs, and the identity of the beneficiaries.
Tax rules change. It is sensible to look at the likely tax consequences alongside the family’s non-tax objectives, rather than assuming that a trust is inherently tax-efficient.
Think about the trustees, not just the beneficiaries
Before creating an ongoing trust, ask who will actually administer it. Trustees may need to deal with investments, property, accounts, tax returns, distributions and disagreements between beneficiaries. Naming someone as a trustee is not simply an honorary role. It will be onerous and time-consuming, sometimes over a lengthy period. The person setting up the trust will need to identify suitable people who understand and are willing to take on those responsibilities.
Sometimes a straightforward Will is the right answer
For many couples and families, a straightforward Will leaving assets outright, with sensible provisions for what happens if a beneficiary dies first, achieves exactly what they need. Other families have genuine reasons to use a trust. The aim should be to choose the simplest arrangement that properly meets your objectives, not the simplest arrangement at any cost.
At Chiltern Wills, we discuss what you want your Will to achieve before recommending how it should be structured. If a trust is appropriate, we will explain why. If it is not, there is no benefit in adding complexity for its own sake.
If you would like advice about making or updating your Will, please contact Chiltern Wills to discuss your circumstances, and we will provide you with a free, no-obligation quote for the work involved.